Soils for the Seeds of Doctrine: Chesterton’s Orthodoxy Turns 100

Art & Literature, Book Reviews — By on November 6, 2008 at 5:11 pm

By Matthew Anderson

I have always thought that every academic–or wannabe, such as myself–ought have one or two hypotheses that are held very loosely, are somewhat defensible but impossible to prove, and just fringe enough to make academic parties mildly interesting.

One such hypothesis that I have occasionally advanced is that G.K. Chesterton’s Orthodoxy is the most important work of the 21st century, even though it was written in the 20th.
Though Chesterton attained more fame during his than C.S. Lewis–he was greeted by massive crowds on his trips around the world– by the beginning of World War Two his position as chief apologist and defender of the faith had been taken over by Lewis. In particular, Chesterton’s influence on American evangelicalism has been relatively non-existent compared to Lewis’s.

And no wonder: Lewis’ Mere Christianity, which has influenced numerous evangelical leaders over the past few decades, is a masterfully written apologetic for the truth of Christianity. The discovery of Lewis helped many evangelicals in the 50s, 60s, 70s, and 80s realize the importance of having a faith that was as intellectual as it was spiritual.

Yet the situation within evangelicalism–and without–has now changed, and Mere Christianity is an apologetic suited to its time. While evangelicals have made significant strides in recovering the life of the mind, it is now en vogue to criticize evangelical Christianity as too propositional. The new generation of post-modern evangelicals is moved more by the story of Christianity than its ideas, and more prone to appeal to the imagination than the intellect.

Such critics would do well to consider Orthodoxy.

Though it was written 100 years ago, Chesterton’s finest work is still relevant. In the most recent issue of First Things, Ralph Wood writes:

“Indeed, we might say that the last century belongs to Chesterton–for in that now one-hundred-year-old book, Orthodoxy, he remarkably prophesied the ailments of both modernism and postmodernism, while adeptly commending Christianity as their double cure.” 

Wood’s article (not available online) highlights Chesterton’s criticism of the “twin insanities of hyper-rationalism and hyper-emotivism,” and Chesterton’s response to those insanities (imagination and the “Doctrine of Conditional Joy”). But while his analysis of Chesterton’s argument is exactly right, his treatment neglects Chesterton’s method. In brief, Chesterton’s poetic-prose articulates a vision of Christianity that is as artistic as it is analytic, and as such is a more effective antidote to the prevailing post-modern sensibilities than any other book I have found.

Before he considers the tenets of Christian theology, Chesterton defends four propositions: “I felt in my bones, first, that the world does not explain itself…The thing is magic, true or false. Second, I came to feel as if magic must have a meaning, and meaning must have some one to mean it…Third, I thought this purpose beautiful in its old design, in spite of its defects, such as dragons. Fourth, that the proper form of thanks to it is some form of humility and restraint: we should thank God for beer and Burgundy by not drinking too much of them.”

It is somewhat misleading to call these ideas ‘propositions’ for Chesterton, or even ‘ideas.’ Rather, he describes them as the “ultimate attitudes toward life, the soils for the seeds of doctrine.” Earlier, he speaks of the “sentiments of elf-land.”

Chesterton’s case for this ethic, of course, is surprisingly poetic–one might even call it artistic. He rejects sociology or even the principles of natural law and instead appeals to child’s experience of fairy stories as his justification. Yet beneath the apparent triviality is a surprisingly sophisticated aim (this dynamic frequently occurs in Chesterton): fundamentally, Chesterton understands that persuasion is as much sentimental as it is rational. By articulating the “Ethics of Elfland,” he lays the poetic foundation for his defense of Christianity, which will come in the following chapters. Chesterton wants to convince your mind–but he wants to woo your heart as well.

Chesterton’s Orthodoxy, then, differs from Mere Christianity precisely in its attempt to ground Christianity not in the propositions of natural law, but in the elemental human and artistic experiences that we begin to neglect as we grow old. It is an attempt, dare I say, to defend and engender a faith that exudes wonder and astonishment at the mystery of reality. But Chesterton had told us as much at the beginning. Orthodoxy is not a “series of deductions,” as he says at the outset, but an attempt “in a vague and personal way, in a set of mental pictures, to state the philosophy in which [he has] come to believe.”[1]

It is this approach that I would argue is perfectly suited for our post-modern age. Chesterton is the anti-Nietsche–a poet-philosopher who understands that unless truth exists, the enterprises of art and beauty are rendered meaningless. What’s more, his method is consistent with his argument: he artistically defends the existence of the truth and grounds Christianity in the pre-rational experience of story–without jeopardizing truth’s existence or fallaciously opposing reason and emotion.

In sum, though Orthodoxy has just turned 100 years old, it remains the single most effective articulation of a Christianity that is intellectually robust, artistically engaged, spiritually sensitive, and historically grounded that I have yet read.

Matthew Anderson specializes at making interesting topics sound arcane and uninteresting. He’s been practicing his art the last four years at MereOrthodoxy.com, where he has bored many, many readers. And he’s not going to apologize for it, either.

————————–
 

[1] This is not to say
that Lewis is uninterested in the dispositions of the heart.  It is simply to point out that Chesterton’s
apologetic is specifically pointed at them.


Tags: ,
  • Reagankid

    It is indeed a time to re-examine the ways that evangelicalism describes itself, much as the Republican party needs to spend some time in self-examination.
    I hope that the leftist illuminati don’t write off evangelicals in the next four years. Obama met with evangelical leaders during the campaign – but I don’t trust that will continue this consideration during his administration, or if he does, that he represents other liberal elitists.

  • http://www.ticketpoint.de Flug

    More and more powerfull
    i love it! this site is very informative, i´ve got searched a long time for sites likes this one…thx for everything…
    greets

  • http://TheEverwiseBoonton.blogspot.com Boonton

    I picked up a bit of Chesterton after catching a bit of a program on the Catholic Channel where Chesterton was described as a “Catholic Mark Twain”. On humor alone the man is a great writer but he is a lot more than that, so I couldn’t agree with you more that he should be read more than he is now. I recently finished The Black Swan and one interesting image the author paints is Uberto Eco’s massive personal library with over 30,000 books. Most people miss the point of the library, pondering whether the man has really read all those books. The point of the library is all the books that haven’t yet been read and the valuable ideas that might be in them.
    Chesterton is one of those valuable writers who has stopped being read and we are a bit worse off for it. People would do well to cut down on a few Lewis books from their reading list and make room for Chesterton.

  • http://www.mereorthodoxy.com Matthew Lee Anderson

    “Chesterton is one of those valuable writers who has stopped being read and we are a bit worse off for it. People would do well to cut down on a few Lewis books from their reading list and make room for Chesterton.”
    Boonton–I couldn’t agree more.

  • http://sunandshield.blogspot.com Martin LaBar

    Thanks for the reminder of the 100th anniversary.

  • Kevin

    “President-elect Obama is certainly not the sort of leader America needs.”
    Oh really?? I wonder if any of you tried reading God’s word? Try Romans 13 1:7
    1 Everyone must submit himself to the governing authorities, for there is no authority except that which God has established. The authorities that exist have been established by God.
    2 Consequently, he who rebels against the authority is rebelling against what God has instituted, and those who do so will bring judgment on themselves.
    3 For rulers hold no terror for those who do right, but for those who do wrong. Do you want to be free from fear of the one in authority? Then do what is right and he will commend you.
    4 For he is God’s servant to do you good. But if you do wrong, be afraid, for he does not bear the sword for nothing. He is God’s servant, an agent of wrath to bring punishment on the wrongdoer.
    5 Therefore, it is necessary to submit to the authorities, not only because of possible punishment but also because of conscience.
    6 This is also why you pay taxes, for the authorities are God’s servants, who give their full time to governing.
    7 Give everyone what you owe him: If you owe taxes, pay taxes; if revenue, then revenue; if respect, then respect; if honor, then honor.
    I would have to believe that God says Obama is the exact President that America needs.

  • Wade M. Nye

    While Chesterton’s writing is powerful, I believe he was known even more for his oral defense of the faith. I saw him demolish the anti-Christian lawyer,Clarence Darrow in a re-eanctment of their debate on public TV. Wow!
    But why debate who was a greater voice, Lewis or Chesterton? They both are still very relevant. Many folks still need to understand Paul’s argument in Romans 1 for natural law, and Lewis reprises it brilliantly.
    I have. perhaps, a more important question. Historically has Christianity impacted culture more by it’s propositional truths or the force of its agape ethic? To paraphrase our Lord, it will not be by your doctrines that all men shall know you are mine, but by the quality of your relationships. I don’t believe the first believers had much use for debating propositonal truth. They were too busy living it. If you are interested in my article on How we can win our generation, you will find my piece, “Our Impssible Dream” at http://www.heapofstones.com

  • http://www.pzyveco.gjnzrsoqt.com wcqryie kgbxcihls

    otbir twnyuqk rzgcyefp juefxvlk pyzhfsmu fmap qzdswbe

  • jb

    “I would have to believe that God says Obama is the exact President that America needs.”
    And the wicked and evil Chaldeans were the EXACT destroyers the Israelites needed. [Habakkuk] The Chaldeans absolutely served God’s purposes. Obama will also serve God’s purposes, perhaps to punish us.

  • jb

    “I would have to believe that God says Obama is the exact President that America needs.”
    And the wicked and evil Chaldeans were the EXACT destroyers the Israelites needed. [Habakkuk] The Chaldeans absolutely served God’s purposes. Obama will also serve God’s purposes, perhaps to punish us.

  • jb

    “I would have to believe that God says Obama is the exact President that America needs.”
    And the wicked and evil Chaldeans were the EXACT destroyers the Israelites needed. [Habakkuk] The Chaldeans absolutely served God’s purposes. Obama will also serve God’s purposes, perhaps to punish us.

  • Stobedero

    I have been integrating this interesting weight loss pill in my routine and I thought I would share with everyone my results. I heard about this supplement through a friend and I ended up getting a trial and started seeing results extremely fast. I couldn’t believe I had actually shed 20lbs in 2 months simply by taking this pill. If you’re curious they give you a free trial, check it out here: The Acai Berry
    Ray E.

  • sluclidly

    Hi guys
    Can I get some advice on teeth Whitening products??
    I would be extremely happy if ya’ll could give any help.

  • Stobedero

    I’ve been integrating this rarely heard of pill in my diet and I thought I would share with everyone my weight loss. I heard about this supplement through a friend and I ended up ordering a trial and started seeing results extremely fast. I could not believe I had actually shed 30 lbs in 1.5 months simply by including this pill. If you’re interested they offer a free trial, check it out here: ACAI BERRY
    Cole F.

  • Stobedero

    I’ve been integrating this new supplement in my structured diet and I thought I would include everyone my results. I heard about this supplement through a gym partner and I ended up getting a trial and started seeing results immediately. I couldn’t believe I had actually shed 30 lbs in 2 months simply by taking this pill. If you’re interested they give you a free trial, check it out by clicking: BUY ACAI BERRY
    Brian F.

  • Tewsideri

    I have been trying to find a pair of HID bulbs for my 1992 GMC and was wondering if someone had any help?
    I have located these websites for specifications but any personal experienced tips would be awesome.
    hid light

  • http://www.toppowerlevel.net wow power leveling

    The cheapest wow power leveling, the most secure wow power leveling, the highest output of wow gold and other games gold, the most honest Warhammer Online Power Leveling. All of the benefits and services at YOYO Game Store (the most professional wow power leveling service providers Traders).

  • http://topvoda.ru TopVoda

    Добрый день! В Сети появился новый сайт по тематике Обработки технической воды. Вот одна из статей сайта:
    Биофлокуляторы

  • http://menu56.ru Anadyr

    Здравствуйте! Не так давно купил себе гаджет в отличном магазине. Всем советую! Доставили очень быстро! Я безмерно рад!
    Магазин по продаже электроники.

  • http://myplokna.ru/ MyPlOkna

    Если быть правдивой, я бы порекомендовала установить Вам кнопку “Подари 5 рублёв”,
    яб с удовольствием перечислила владельцу 5 рублей. А вы? ;-)
    Супер окна