War of the Words: Israel and the U.S.Foreign Affairs, Global War on Terrorism, Judaism, Other, Other Religions, Politics, Religion — By Rachel Motte on June 14, 2010 at 1:01 am
As Israel struggles to stay afloat beneath the nearly universal condemnation of its conduct in the recent flotilla incident, I can’t help wondering: When did racism suddenly become so socially acceptable – and even fashionable – in the U.S.?
To be sure, the decades-long struggle between Israel, Palestine, and the rest of the world is far from simple, and atrocities have doubtless been committed by both sides. War is ugly, and we are rightly repulsed by it. We make an enormous tactical mistake, however, when we allow this to separate us form our long-time ally–because that is exactly what our mutual enemy hopes for. The U.S. government is doing no one any favors by distancing itself from Israel’s recent actions—no one, that is, except the flotilla organizers. They depended on just this sort of reaction to solidify Israel’s place as Most Hated Nation. By making their own enemy the enemy of the civilized world, the Islamists behind the flotilla have gained an entirely new set of friends and potential allies.
Anti-Zionism is often merely a half step away from anti-Semitism. Though the two ideologies are not precisely identical—anti-Semitism was around long before the state of Israel existed—they are very closely related—so closely related, in fact, that in stoking the flames of anti-Zionism across the globe, the organizers of the flotilla have, at least temporarily, made anti-Semitism a Western virtue. And almost no one has noticed.
Israel’s account of the events leading up to this week’s international outrage is fairly straightforward. In fact, it’s the only unambiguous part of this whole PR nightmare. Every other nation’s reaction has been so heavily contextualized with emotions and memories of past events that it’s a wonder we know what happened at all.
This is intentional. Cold, hard facts are easy to confirm or deny; symbols are not. The flotilla, its cargo, and its passengers were selected to confuse the issues by serving as a symbol of Israeli aggression or of Palestinian hardship or of . . . whatever else it might take to turn the world against Israel. Mostly, it was intended to spark anti-Zionist and anti-Semitic sentiments all over the globe. It worked.
The international media’s emotional outrage is clearly about a lot more than just the deaths of the protestors on the flotilla. It’s about the much longer struggle, stretched out over decades, between Israel and Palestine. It’s about the resentments on both sides, and about how hard it is to wait patiently for a resolution between two competing worldviews. And it’s about the belief, implicit in all these frustrations, that the world would be a better place without both Israel and the Jewish people.
In other words, it’s about the Islamist narrative.
Why is the leadership of our government buying into this narrative? It’s not a narrative that will ever be good for the U.S. Neglecting our longstanding relationship with Israel will merely lead to the deterioration with our other Middle Eastern alliances. With Iran so close to developing a nuclear weapons arsenal, we cannot afford to cause unnecessary shifts in the balance of power. Not only can we not afford to alienate our ally, but we also can’t afford to endorse anti-Semitism in any form—not only because it is wrong, but also because where anti-Semitism thrives, anti-Americanism too often follows.
Yet we are endorsing it, as is the rest of the world, when we refuse to give Israel a fair trial. This is not to say that Israel is incapable of error or that we should support our ally without reservation or precondition. Like all nations, Israel is a flawed state composed of imperfect people. But in being so quick to assume that the international media narrative is correct, we are opening ourselves to exactly the sort of feelings and opinions that our enemies have been hoping for.
Islamists have ennobled their own position in the world by making Israel a global outcast. They’ve encouraged us to turn against one of our best allies, endangering our own security in the process. They’ve also enflamed the anti-Semitic suspicion and hatred that is frequently associated with anti-American convictions.
The media frenzy surrounding the flotilla will quickly subside and most of us will forget about it within weeks. But next time Israel acts in a way that the world doesn’t approve of, it will be easier for us to uncritically condemn them, and easier for us to learn to hate them. If we don’t stop ourselves we will become so much like our enemies that they will defeat us without our even noticing. ‘