On Tuesday, Dennis Prager made a comment on his radio program that without dogma (specifically religious dogma) there can be no rational argument against selfishness and cruelty.
A young man called into the program, describing himself as a Libertarian and an agnostic, to say that you don’t need dogma to be moral. “I never said that”, responded Prager. He then asked the young man a simple question, “What would you say to a rich slave owner?” The young man answered that it causes him intense discomfort to see other human beings suffering. Prager responded that it doesn’t cause the slaver owner any discomfort. Continue reading “Who Sez?” The Place of God in Moral Philosophy
For a long time now, a close friend of mine has been content to call himself agnostic. We don’t talk about it often, but we did a couple weeks ago. I had a long conversation with him via Facebook, going back and forth on various things. Nothing seemed to sink in: It seemed as though we ended the conversation in roughly the exact same place we had started it: firmly planted in agnosticism.
“That’s a dangerous valley you’re in, dude,” I told him.
“Well, that depends on who’s right,” he said. “But I understand what you mean.”
Then he said he had to go and thanked me for the talk. I told him I’d pray for him, and he said he appreciated it.
But I’m not so sure he would still appreciate it, if he knew what I had prayed for. Continue reading A Strange Prayer